I have been renting Condo's in Navarre Beach for about 30 years and have tried many of them. Keep in mind Negotiation is the key to finding the best prices. Shoulder seasons in May and September/ October are great times to go and get the best deals with the least amount of people. I never pay posted prices on VRBO or the real estate web page. Find what building you want then begin a search for the right unit by making multiple phone calls and be firm but realistic regarding what your budget is -
I usually say I have a budget of ____ and want to stay at The Pearl - do you have any units that are available during these dates for this budget?
Remember these are owners and/or real estate agents representing owners. They have high maintenance fees and taxes. You cannot expect to get a beach front view and multiple bedroom condo for the same price as a motel 6. That old adage you get what you pay for is somewhat true but a savvy shopper can get much more than they pay for if they ask for it. Usually the highest end units are easily rented for the same price as the lower end units during shoulder season. God Luck - below are some of my observations and opinions regarding specific buildings.
Last year I rented from
http://www.navarrevacationrentals.com - Thane Creech --and found it to be the best experience so far- My Unit was at The Pearl #504 - I like renting at The Pearl because it's down the beach from Summerwind and upscale furnishings and decor in most units. The grounds are well kept.
I refuse to rent at Summerwind ever again. The crowds of people on the beach are very unpleasant. The Summerwind condo's are ok- the last time I stayed in a penthouse unit that was very nice with a private hot tub. It's the sheer number of people at that property that keep me from going back.
For years I rented at Navarre Towers - however, I have not been there in about 8 years - it became just too run down for me. If I am going to pay for vacation property I want to it to be at least as nice as my own home and most of the furniture and decor during my last few rentals appeared to come from Dollar Tree.
Next door to Navarre Towers is one of my favorite properties - Belle Mer- It's far away from Summerwind on a quiet area of the Island and has very large units with nice balconies. Not many owners rent these units so they can be hard to find and most are 3 or 4 bedrooms which is usually larger than my group needs. If you stay here be sure to get a higher unit in the building so you can have the views. Next door are several houses where weddings occur daily- if you are on a low floor there can be lots of noise and the building has many full time residents who are less tolerant of misbehaving children than other properties. My children are grown but I saw them evict a renter because their child threw a noodle over the balcony into the pool from the 3rd floor. Kids will be kids….. and this did not seem to be the crime they made it out to be.
Next Door to the Pearl is a newer development - I have not stayed there because their views are blocked by other buildings - Not sure why anyone built such nice condo's back so far they had a blocked view.
Caribbean Resort is on the West Side of The Pearl - I toured the building once and found it smelled musty and old. A local resident told me they have serious structural problems since the last Hurricane and sewer issues are causing the smell. It looked nice just walking through but again I don't want to spend my hard earned vacation time and money staying in something with bad smells and potential structural issues.